All I can say is you guys obviously did not hear a fraction of the crap I did on trackwrestling. The board spent hours on the phone and working emails to get this done. That doesn't even take into account the issues with getting league USA cards. And believe me (or check with Keith Smith), there are issues here as well. I'm not saying it is a nightmare for me personally, but many around the state would say it is. And I personally do not believe this will do much to impact weight cutting.
JW - it is being done at the high school level where coaches and programs are much more structured, have more help, and managed by administrations. While we all expect that to happen everywhere even at the middle school level, the reality is that many programs are not run at the same efficiency level. There may only be one coach involved who is not a teacher and tries to juggle everything. The job should get done, but the bottm line is that it doesn't.
As far as what the kids want, my son may love candy bars and ice cream, but that doesn't mean it is the best thing in the world for him and everyone else. Kids generally only consider what is affecting them and maybe a couple of their buddies in the last week. Again, I'm for making smart, logical change for the better, not change for the sake of change.