Please quit with the comparison of High School to Middle School. There is alot of difference in muscle tone, strength and maturity between a 16 to 18 year old that the 2lb allowance was designed for and an 11 - 13 year old that is in question here. Bottom line when you have weight classes as close as most of the middle school weights are there should not be a weight allowance.....at all. Make weight and wrestle or wrestle up the next class. It is easy to argue based on what helps YOUR kid from either direction, but get rid of the debate next year and get rid of weight allowances. If anything give 1 pound during the holiday season but remove it 1 week after schools are back open. This removes the entire debate of stupidity. Allowance was implemented for growth purposes and nobody here is using it for that purpose. So lets get rid of it all together.